--- title: Levies on Refurbished Devices in court description: "Levies on Refurbished Devices in court\nAbgaben auf refurbishde Geräte: Gerichtsverfahren in Frankreich" image: https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/hubfs/Justizia%20Frankreich-2.png ---                  [+49 7031 4 39 38 – 0](tel:+49%207031439380)                              [info@1cc-consulting.com](mailto:info@1cc-consulting.com)                                      [de](https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/de?hsLang=en) [![1cc-consulting](https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/6783864/1cc_Consulting_February2020/Images/logo-1cc.jpg)](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/) - [Home](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/) - [Services](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/) - [Regulatory Monitoring](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/regulatory-monitoring/) - [Individual Consulting](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/individual-consulting/) - [Management & Admin Services](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/management-admin-services/) - Others - [Auditing](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/auditing/) - [Business Services](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/business-services/) - [Compliance Check](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/compliance-check/) - [Standards & Certification](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/standards-certification/) - [Competencies](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/competencies/) - Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) - [Electrical- and Electronic Equipment (WEEE)](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/weee/) - [Batteries](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/batteries/) - [Packaging](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/packaging/) - [Transborder Shipment of Waste](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/transborder-shipment-of-waste/) - [Textiles and Furniture](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/extended-producer-responsibility-epr/) - Product Compliance & Sustainability - [RoHS / CE](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/rohs-en/) - [REACH](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/reach-en/) - [Conflict Minerals](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/conflict-minerals/) - [Ecodesign (ERP)](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/erp-en/) - [Product Carbon Footprint](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/product-carbon-footprint/) - [Green Public Procurement](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/green-public-procurement/) - [German Supply Chain Due diligence Act](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/german-supply-chain-due-diligence-act/) - [Copyright Levies](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/copyright/) - [Company](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/this-is-1cc/) - [Career](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/company/jobs/) - [1cc Team](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/company/locations/) - [References](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/company/references/) - [ISO certification](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/company/iso-90012015-and-iso-140012015/) - [Blog](https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/en) - [Webinar](https://webinar.1cc-consulting.com/en) - [Contact](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/contact/) - [Home](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/) - [Services](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/) - [Regulatory Monitoring](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/regulatory-monitoring/) - [Individual Consulting](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/individual-consulting/) - [Management & Admin Services](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/management-admin-services/) - Others - [Auditing](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/auditing/) - [Business Services](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/business-services/) - [Compliance Check](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/compliance-check/) - [Standards & Certification](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/services-en/standards-certification/) - [Competencies](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/competencies/) - Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) - [Electrical- and Electronic Equipment (WEEE)](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/weee/) - [Batteries](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/batteries/) - [Packaging](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/packaging/) - [Transborder Shipment of Waste](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/transborder-shipment-of-waste/) - [Textiles and Furniture](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/extended-producer-responsibility-epr/) - Product Compliance & Sustainability - [RoHS / CE](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/rohs-en/) - [REACH](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/reach-en/) - [Conflict Minerals](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/conflict-minerals/) - [Ecodesign (ERP)](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/erp-en/) - [Product Carbon Footprint](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/product-carbon-footprint/) - [Green Public Procurement](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/green-public-procurement/) - [German Supply Chain Due diligence Act](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/german-supply-chain-due-diligence-act/) - [Copyright Levies](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/portfolio/copyright/) - [Company](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/this-is-1cc/) - [Career](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/company/jobs/) - [1cc Team](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/company/locations/) - [References](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/company/references/) - [ISO certification](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/company/iso-90012015-and-iso-140012015/) - [Blog](https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/en) - [Webinar](https://webinar.1cc-consulting.com/en) - [Contact](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/contact/) ### Welcome to the 1cc Blog ### 22 Jan 2024 ### [Levies on Refurbished Devices in court](https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/en/levies-on-refurbished-devices-in-court) On 22 , Jan 2024 | In | By Wolfram Kühn [![Levies on Refurbished Devices in court](https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Justizia%20Frankreich-2.png?width=550&name=Justizia%20Frankreich-2.png)](https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/en/levies-on-refurbished-devices-in-court) Around forty French and foreign refurbishers are being prosecuted in France because of copyright levy obligations on refurbished devices. Those companies had been initially approached and asked to submit their figures for all devices sold in France. The claims being made against them range from several hundred thousands to several million euros. More remarkable than the anticipated sum of levies is the long retrospective period deemed valid . Three providers have now objected to ongoing proceedings: The German provider Handydortmund.de, the French providers WeFix.fr and Smaaart.fr are disputing the legal basis for levy obligations for the period prior to 2021. Despite a clear legal foundation for claims made for the period after that, they have put forward familiar fundamental arguments against the levy demands made. These mainly relate to the multiple charges for one and the same device – once upon its placement on the market as a new device and then again (theoretically even several times) as a refurbished product. This confirms in practice what we had already published in a [previous blog in 2023](https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/en/copyright-levy-obligations-for-refurbished-devices-always-existed?hsLang=en): The obligation to pay a levy on professionally inspected, cleaned, repaired (if necessary) and then resold used devices is not a novelty. It has either always existed or goes back much longer than the current discussion makes it appear. [![Contact us](https://hubspot-no-cache-eu1-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/cta/default/25955255/6c19cc72-7b0a-4bb6-99da-3f2ec2a7e5e3.png)](https://hubspot-cta-redirect-eu1-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/cta/redirect/25955255/6c19cc72-7b0a-4bb6-99da-3f2ec2a7e5e3) [![Share on facebook](https://7528309.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hub/7528309/hubfs/raw_assets/public/mV0_d-web-default-modules_hubspot/img/facebook-color.png?width=24&name=facebook-color.png)](https://www.linkedin.com/company/2355686/admin/) [![Share on linkedin](https://7528302.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hub/7528302/hubfs/raw_assets/public/mV0_d-web-default-modules_hubspot/img/linkedin-color.png?width=24&name=linkedin-color.png)](https://www.linkedin.com/company/2355686/admin/) [![Share on twitter](https://7528304.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hub/7528304/hubfs/raw_assets/public/mV0_d-web-default-modules_hubspot/img/twitter-color.png?width=24&name=twitter-color.png)](https://twitter.com/1cc_consulting) [![Share on email](https://7528311.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hub/7528311/hubfs/raw_assets/public/mV0_d-web-default-modules_hubspot/img/email-color.png?width=24&name=email-color.png)](mailto:info@1cc-consulting.com) ### Archives - [June 2026 (8)](https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/en/archive/2026/06) - [May 2026 (6)](https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/en/archive/2026/05) - [April 2026 (7)](https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/en/archive/2026/04) - [March 2026 (12)](https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/en/archive/2026/03) - [February 2026 (7)](https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/en/archive/2026/02) ### Subscribe to our blog and never miss news again [Imprint](https://1cc-consulting.com/en/imprint/)     |     [Privacy Policy](https://1cc-consulting.com/wp-content/uploads/datenschutz_en.pdf)     |     [Data Processing Agreement](https://1cc-consulting.com/wp-content/uploads/1cc_Data-Processing-Agreement.pdf)     |     [AGB](https://1cc-consulting.com/wp-content/uploads/1cc_GTC.pdf)     |     [1cc Reporting Tool](https://reporting.1cc-consulting.com/Account/Login?ReturnUrl=%2F)     |     [1cc Compliance Data](https://asp.selltec.de/go/onecc/home/community_login,l-en.html?_login_redirect=true)     |     [4 Square Return](https://4square-return.com/en) ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Wolfram Kühn", "url" : "https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/en/author/wolfram-kühn" }, "dateModified" : "2024-01-22T12:59:56.665Z", "datePublished" : "2024-01-22T12:03:08.000Z", "headline" : "Levies on Refurbished Devices in court", "image" : [ "https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/hubfs/Justizia%20Frankreich-2.png" ], "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/en/levies-on-refurbished-devices-in-court", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://blog.1cc-consulting.com/hubfs/Logo/1cc_Logo_RGB_freigestellt.png" }, "name" : "1cc GmbH" } } ```